Low-carbon fuels could lose emphasis from Trump EPA

Cellulosic ethanol made from crops like switchgrass generates 60 percent less greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline. (Photo by Grant Gerlock, NET News/Harvest Public Media)
Listen to this story: 

July 27, 2017 - 6:45am

The EPA wants to reduce the amount of fuel in our gasoline supply that is made from plants and generates far less carbon dioxide than gasoline or corn ethanol. That has some concerned the Trump Administration plans to pull back from low-carbon fuels.

On a sweltering summer morning, Rob Mitchell surveys a plot of switchgrass at a research field near Lincoln, Nebraska. The grass is lush, green and nearly six feet tall.

“And it will get a couple feet taller than this,” says Mitchell, an agronomist with the U.S. Department of Agriculture. “So we’re putting on a lot of biomass right now.”

The grass growing in the research plot is Liberty Switchgrass, a perennial variety bred to grow quickly and produce more plant material, or biomass, than other switchgrass. The cellulose fiber in the biomass can be broken down to make what’s called cellulosic ethanol, fuel that when blended with gasoline can run our cars.

Currently, nearly all of the ethanol burned in cars in the U.S. is made from corn. Energy crops like switchgrass are thought of as the second generation of biofuel, new technology with a smaller carbon footprint.

The Environmental Protection Agency recently announced a plan to reduce the amount of cellulosic ethanol it requires oil refiners to mix into our gasoline supply. Right now, the fuel in that category mostly comes from renewable natural gas made from sources like methane collected from landfills, not switchgrass. That has some concerned that the Trump Administration plans to pull back from innovation in renewable fuels, such as technology that could make switchgrass viable.

Switchgrass is good for making fuel, Mitchell says, because it grows well in fields that have poor soil on which farmers often lose money planting corn.

“On marginally productive land where maybe corn and soybeans aren’t best suited for the long term, switchgrass or the other native perennials fit very well,” Mitchell says.

It also has environmental benefits. Switchgrass roots grow deep. They pull carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it in the soil and can help filter farm chemicals out of water that washes off of crop fields.

Today, though, drivers can’t fuel up with ethanol made from switchgrass. The only commercial-scale cellulosic ethanol comes from two facilities in Iowa using corn stalks. Switchgrass may be ready for the field, but until the science improves, converting it into ethanol is not cost effective.

“It’s just really hard to do at any large scale,” says Scott Irwin, an economist with the University of Illinois. “Especially when you’re competing against corn-based ethanol which is a very well developed technology and you can obviously do it pretty cheaply.”

Even so, the federal government requires certain types of renewable fuel to be mixed in the nation’s fuel supply. Cellulosic ethanol is featured in that policy, Irwin says, because it’s so carbon friendly. But that could be changing.

“We all know about the Obama administration’s support for the Paris accords and climate change and so on,” Irwin says. “Clearly, the Trump administration is going in the other direction. So it’s not surprising to me that we see a small cutback.”

In its proposal for the 2018 Renewable Fuel Standard, the law that governs the amount of biofuels in the gasoline supply, the EPA is proposing a cut of 73 million gallons from the 311 million gallons of cellulosic ethanol category in this year’s mandate. The agency says it’s still leaving room for growth, but it’s responding to the market. Cellulosic ethanol is expensive and the industry has lagged behind production targets.

Overall, oil refiners are required to use 19.28 billion gallons of renewable fuels in 2017. The EPA proposal would lower that to 19.24 billion gallons in 2018. The EPA is taking comments and is expected to finalize the 2018 numbers in November.

Cellulosic ethanol production was costly and slow to develop during the Obama Administration, too. However, the EPA made a point of increasing the amount of cellulosic ethanol each year, even by small amounts.

“For us, that was a very important signal to maintain in the rule,” says Janet McCabe, a former administrator at the EPA during the Obama years. “That’s what Congress had said and this (proposal) doesn’t do that.”

In the years ahead, the Trump EPA will likely have the chance to reset biofuel policy more broadly. The Renewable Fuel Standard passed by Congress in 2007 includes a reset provision. After consecutive years where the final mandate is more than 20 percent lower than the amount lawmakers called for, the EPA is allowed to redraw the trajectory for renewable fuel use in the U.S. for following years. The reset provision could be triggered in the fall of 2018.

Supporters of cellulosic ethanol are concerned that a renewable fuel revamp by the Trump administration could give up on low-carbon fuels made from energy crops like switchgrass.

“Part of the idea of a multi-year approach is to build a market for cleaner fuels that we’ll need in the distant future and not to dismantle that because of what gas costs today,” says Jeremy Martin, who studies biofuel policy for the Union for Concerned Scientists.

If federal policy does not carve out a space for cellulosic ethanol, Janet McCabe says the oil industry and corn ethanol producers are unlikely to make room for competition.

“You have stakeholders that just can’t accommodate each other,” McCabe says. “The more you have of fuel X, the less you have to have of fuel Y.”

Without a guaranteed market, investors will be hard pressed to put their money into cellulosic technology. That means farmers will have little reason to plant switchgrass.

“Farmers are very adaptable,” says USDA researcher Rob Mitchell. “If you give them an opportunity to make money and give them realistic goals they can meet those quickly.”

For now, switchgrass remains on the sidelines as the Trump administration begins to put its mark on the future of renewable energy.

Editor's Note: This story was updated to reflect the amount of renewable natural gas that qualifies under the cellulosic category in the EPA's Renewable Fuel Standard.

Harvest Public Media is a reporting collaboration focused on issues of food, fuel and field. Harvest covers these agriculture-related topics through an expanding network of reporters and partner stations throughout the Midwest.



blog comments powered by Disqus